ForkFree

Prompts / Writing

Build a Scoring Rubric From Good Examples

It turns a handful of proven examples into a short, fair scoring rubric, then marks your draft against it. You get a score, the weakest point and one fix, which is easier to act on than general feedback.

Worked in our testThe reply gave a clear rubric table, quoted evidence, a total, a weakest question and a fix. It slipped on three points. The fix runs to two sentences but adds a second instruction beyond a single fix. The weakest question was picked arbitrarily from a tie. Q2 and Q6 mix several criteria, which weakens reviewer consistency. The structure analysis also skips the order of the moves.

The prompt

Act as an experienced editor who turns good examples into clear, repeatable quality checks.

Task: Build a scoring rubric from the effective examples below, then use it to assess my draft.

Examples of {work_type} that performed well:
{example_pieces}

My draft:
{draft_text}

Steps:
1. Study the examples and identify what they share in structure: the moves they make, the order they make them in, and what they avoid. Ignore surface style, tone and vocabulary.
2. Write {question_count} yes-or-no style questions, each scored 0, 1 or 2. Define what each score means so two different reviewers would give the same mark.
3. Score my draft against every question, quoting a short phrase from the draft as evidence.
4. Add up the total and identify the weakest question.
5. Suggest one specific fix for that weakest question.

Output: First the rubric as a table (question, 0, 1, 2). Then the draft's total score out of the maximum, the weakest question, and one suggested fix in no more than three sentences.

Change the parts in curly braces. Use it when you write the same kind of piece repeatedly, such as pitches or sales pages, and want consistent feedback; refresh the examples every few months.

What happened when we ran it

We sent

Act as an experienced editor who turns good examples into clear, repeatable quality checks.

Task: Build a scoring rubric from the effective examples below, then use it to assess my draft.

Examples of cold pitch emails from freelance designers to small business owners that performed well:
Example 1: Subject: Your menu photos. Hi Tom, I noticed your new menu online but the photos make the dishes look flat. I redesigned a similar menu for Bay Cafe and their takeaway orders rose 18% in a month. Would a 10-minute call on Thursday suit you? Example 2: Subject: Quick idea for your shop window. Hi Priya, I walked past your florist on Mill Road and loved the displays. Your website doesn't show them. I could build a simple gallery page in a week for a fixed fee. Shall I send a sketch? Example 3: Subject: Fixing your booking form. Hi Sam, three of your reviews mention trouble booking online. I fixed the same issue for a local physio and missed bookings dropped to near zero. Happy to show you how. Free for a call this week?

My draft:
Hi there, I'm a passionate and creative designer with over ten years of experience in branding, web design and print. I would love the opportunity to work with your company and help it grow. Please see my portfolio attached and let me know if you have any work available.

Steps:
1. Study the examples and identify what they share in structure: the moves they make, the order they make them in, and what they avoid. Ignore surface style, tone and vocabulary.
2. Write 6 yes-or-no style questions, each scored 0, 1 or 2. Define what each score means so two different reviewers would give the same mark.
3. Score my draft against every question, quoting a short phrase from the draft as evidence.
4. Add up the total and identify the weakest question.
5. Suggest one specific fix for that weakest question.

Output: First the rubric as a table (question, 0, 1, 2). Then the draft's total score out of the maximum, the weakest question, and one suggested fix in no more than three sentences.

The model replied

**Shared structure in the examples:** a subject line naming something specific to the recipient, a greeting by name, a concrete observation about the recipient's business, a named problem or opportunity, evidence of a past result or a defined offer, and one low-effort call to action. They avoid self-description, adjectives about the sender, and vague offers. ## Rubric | # | Question | 0 | 1 | 2 | |---|---|---|---|---| | 1 | Does the subject line name something specific to the recipient's business? | Missing, or generic (e.g. "Designer available") | Mentions the recipient's field but nothing specific (e.g. "Design help") | Names a specific asset, page or problem of theirs (e.g. "Your menu photos") | | 2 | Is the recipient addressed by name? | No greeting or "Hi there"/"Dear Sir" | Business name only, or a role | First name of an individual | | 3 | Does it open with a concrete observation about the recipient's business? | None | Generic praise or a remark that could apply to any business | A specific, verifiable detail about their site, shop, reviews or menu | | 4 | Does it identify a specific problem or opportunity for them? | None; only the sender's wish to work together | A broad claim ("help you grow") | A named, specific issue or opportunity | | 5 | Does it offer proof of a result or a defined deliverable? | Only claims about the sender (years, passion) | Portfolio link or a vague claim of past work | A named comparable client with a result, or a concrete deliverable with timeframe or fee | | 6 | Does it end with one small, specific call to action? | None, or an open-ended "let me know if you have work" | A single request, but vague or high effort | One low-effort ask with a time or format (call Thursday, send a sketch) | **Maximum: 12** ## Scoring your draft | # | Evidence | Score | |---|---|---| | 1 | No subject line supplied | 0 | | 2 | "Hi there" | 0 | | 3 | "work with your company": nothing specific observed | 0 | | 4 | "help it grow": broad, unspecific | 1 | | 5 | "over ten years of experience", "see my portfolio attached": self-claims plus a portfolio, no result | 1 | | 6 | "let me know if you have any work available": open-ended, puts the burden on them | 0 | **Total: 2 / 12** **Weakest question:** Q3 (concrete observation). It is tied for lowest at 0, but it is the root cause: without a specific observation, you can't name a problem (Q4), offer proof that fits (Q5), or craft a targeted subject line (Q1). **Suggested fix:** Spend two minutes on each recipient's website or reviews and open with one specific detail, such as "Your homepage photos hide the product range." Then build the rest of the email around that detail, replacing "passionate and creative" with a single result you've achieved for a similar business.

Run on Claude Sonnet 5.5, 07 Nov 2026. Automatic check: 4 out of 5.

Mentioned for

Claude, ChatGPT, Gemini

Where it came from

Found on Web, shared by Don Giannatti (In the Frame), adapting a prompt from Lea of Excellent AI Prompts (issue of 2 Nov): AI for Creatives — Week of November 6, 2026.

This is our own version of the idea, written and tested by us. The original may differ.

More writing prompts

Writing Struggled in our test
Rewrite Machine-Sounding Text Without Inventing Facts

You get a rewrite that sounds like a person wrote it, with a clear list of what was changed. The locked fact list stops the model inventing statistics or stories to seem more human.

Found on GitHub, shared by yucezerey
Writing Worked in our test
Add One Missing Requirement to Drafts

You get one targeted addition to your prompt instead of a full rewrite, with a reason for it. It works because the AI must first list what is already good, so your original wording and constraints are preserved.

Found on GitHub, shared by dbcaskml183-dotcom
Writing Worked in our test
Stretchtext Replies With Expandable Detail

You get a short answer that grows in controlled layers, with each new addition highlighted so nothing is repeated or lost. It works because each level is forced to keep the earlier words, so the reader stays oriented as detail is added.

Found on GitHub, shared by pro-vi