Build a Scoring Rubric From Good Examples
It turns a handful of proven examples into a short, fair scoring rubric, then marks your draft against it. You get a score, the weakest point and one fix, which is easier to act on than general feedback.
The prompt
Act as an experienced editor who turns good examples into clear, repeatable quality checks.
Task: Build a scoring rubric from the effective examples below, then use it to assess my draft.
Examples of {work_type} that performed well:
{example_pieces}
My draft:
{draft_text}
Steps:
1. Study the examples and identify what they share in structure: the moves they make, the order they make them in, and what they avoid. Ignore surface style, tone and vocabulary.
2. Write {question_count} yes-or-no style questions, each scored 0, 1 or 2. Define what each score means so two different reviewers would give the same mark.
3. Score my draft against every question, quoting a short phrase from the draft as evidence.
4. Add up the total and identify the weakest question.
5. Suggest one specific fix for that weakest question.
Output: First the rubric as a table (question, 0, 1, 2). Then the draft's total score out of the maximum, the weakest question, and one suggested fix in no more than three sentences.
Change the parts in curly braces. Use it when you write the same kind of piece repeatedly, such as pitches or sales pages, and want consistent feedback; refresh the examples every few months.
What happened when we ran it
We sent
Act as an experienced editor who turns good examples into clear, repeatable quality checks. Task: Build a scoring rubric from the effective examples below, then use it to assess my draft. Examples of cold pitch emails from freelance designers to small business owners that performed well: Example 1: Subject: Your menu photos. Hi Tom, I noticed your new menu online but the photos make the dishes look flat. I redesigned a similar menu for Bay Cafe and their takeaway orders rose 18% in a month. Would a 10-minute call on Thursday suit you? Example 2: Subject: Quick idea for your shop window. Hi Priya, I walked past your florist on Mill Road and loved the displays. Your website doesn't show them. I could build a simple gallery page in a week for a fixed fee. Shall I send a sketch? Example 3: Subject: Fixing your booking form. Hi Sam, three of your reviews mention trouble booking online. I fixed the same issue for a local physio and missed bookings dropped to near zero. Happy to show you how. Free for a call this week? My draft: Hi there, I'm a passionate and creative designer with over ten years of experience in branding, web design and print. I would love the opportunity to work with your company and help it grow. Please see my portfolio attached and let me know if you have any work available. Steps: 1. Study the examples and identify what they share in structure: the moves they make, the order they make them in, and what they avoid. Ignore surface style, tone and vocabulary. 2. Write 6 yes-or-no style questions, each scored 0, 1 or 2. Define what each score means so two different reviewers would give the same mark. 3. Score my draft against every question, quoting a short phrase from the draft as evidence. 4. Add up the total and identify the weakest question. 5. Suggest one specific fix for that weakest question. Output: First the rubric as a table (question, 0, 1, 2). Then the draft's total score out of the maximum, the weakest question, and one suggested fix in no more than three sentences.
The model replied
Run on Claude Sonnet 5.5, 07 Nov 2026. Automatic check: 4 out of 5.
Mentioned for
Claude, ChatGPT, Gemini
Where it came from
Found on Web, shared by Don Giannatti (In the Frame), adapting a prompt from Lea of Excellent AI Prompts (issue of 2 Nov): AI for Creatives — Week of November 6, 2026.
This is our own version of the idea, written and tested by us. The original may differ.